menu
menu Ice Cream Flavors Seasonal Flavors Fat and Dairy Free Fruit Sorbets Low-Fat Frozen Yogurts Sundaes Shakes & Malts Double Dip Sodas Signature Treats Fresh Fruit Smoothies Homemade Ice Cream Cakes Homemade Ice Cream Pies download menu

Homemade Ice Cream Pies

All of our pies are round, nine inches in diameter, and serve about eight to ten people. All are iced only with real whipped cream.

TURTLE

Honey graham crust, Butter Pecan ice cream, caramel, fudge, garnished with pecans.

CHOCOLATE MINT

Chocolate crust, Mint Chip ice cream, fudge, garnished with chocolate shavings.

COOKIES & CREAM

Chocolate crust, Cookies & Cream ice cream, fudge, garnished with crushed Oreos™.

BUCKEYE

Chocolate crust, Peanut Butter Chip ice cream, fudge, garnished with chocolate shavings.

CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER CUP

Chocolate crust, Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup ice cream, peanut butter sauce, fudge, garnished with crushed Reese’s™ cups. We will gladly make you a custom cake or pie that is not on our menu with two days notice. back to top

  • Mitchells Homemade main logo
  • Home link to home page
  • Store link to store hours
  • Menu link to menu
  • Birthday link to birthday information
  • Catering link to catering and events
  • Community link to community
  • Fun Stuff link to fun stuff
  • Gifts a link to fun stuff
  • Careers
  • Fundraising a link to fundraising
  • Contact a link to the contact page